Invisible Mandates
The Myth of Responsibility Without Authority
Listen to this essay free, on PR After Hours.
My friend, a seasoned marketer and product‑management support specialist, was laid off recently—a gut punch that reminded me of an odd metaphor I’ve used for years: Claude Rains in The Invisible Man.
By middle age, you can start to feel just as invisible in corporate life—expected to drive results, but unseen when it comes to budget, headcount, or influence.
You got Claude Rains-ed.
She was handed a mandate: improve efficiency, speed production, and break silos. But with no team, budget, or decision-making power, that’s like giving someone a seat in a Formula One car but no access to the steering wheel, brakes, or accelerator.
Also known as: Mission: Impossible.
The Corporate Unfunded Mandate
A true unfunded mandate in government is when higher authorities require action without funding it—think federal orders to enhance air quality or school accessibility without granting funds. The Clean Air Act of 1990 famously required states to meet pollution targets, but left them scrambling for money.
In business, the equivalent happens when employees are told to deliver strategic initiatives—streamline processes, launch new offerings—without resources, headcount, or authority.
It feels noble; it’s actually professional suicide.
Why It’s So Common
Flat org charts & power vacuums: accountability is vague; authority is siloed.
Risk‑averse delegators: leaders assign “leads” but hold power close.
Results‑only reviews: reward outcomes, penalize delays—ignore the conditions.
CultureAlly puts it sharply: “With great responsibility…comes no power.”
The Toll on People
It costs us talent. Gallup reports that only 31% of U.S. employees are fully engaged, while 17% are actively disengaged—the worst figures since 2014. Shockingly, only 46% understand their roles clearly, down from 56% in March 2020.
Confusion, frustration…and pink slips follow.
Influence Over Authority
The PMI survey found 87% of top project managers identify influencing stakeholders—not formal authority—as the critical success factor.
They also report massive waste:
9.9% of every dollar is squandered due to poor project performance—around $99 million per $1 billion.
Organizations with mature project practices (“champions”) waste 21 times less than underperformers and complete 92% of projects successfully versus just 33% for low performers.
Even reducing waste: from $122 million per $1 billion in 2016 to $97 million in 2017—a 20% improvement.
Poor requirements management alone accounts for 5.1% waste—$51 million per $1 billion.
Failed projects drain $135 million per $1 billion, or 13.5%.
In short: without influence—and structure—mandates become money pits.
How I’ve Navigated It and Other Tactics
When you’re invisible, borrow visibility:
Invoke the C‑suite
Position your initiative as commissioned by the VP or a similarly powerful exec. Suddenly, you're not rogue—you’re a proxy.Map and manage stakeholders
Identify decision-makers and gatekeepers early. HBS recommends one-on-one alignment to build agreement.Turn expertise into soft authority
Be recognized as the knowledge-holder. With credibility comes influence—even without a title.Lead with cost-benefit clarity
Present clear ROI, trade-offs, and risks upfront.Escalate tactfully
When all else fails, respectfully request executive sponsorship or a formal mandate.
When you can’t get the resources, become the resourceful proxy for someone who can.
What Leaders Often Misjudge
Delegation ≠ enablement: handing responsibility without authority is dodging accountability.
Visibility bias kills quiet labor: The fixation on visibility often sidelines introverted employees. Not everyone thrives in an extroverted workplace culture where success is measured by who talks the most or stays constantly in the spotlight. Some of the most effective performers are quiet, deliberate, and results-driven—even if they’re not raising their hand every five minutes or posting about every minor win. Bottom line: the invisible get culled first in downsizing.
Clarity is everything: as Gallup shows, role understanding is the foundation of engagement.
The Invisible Get Ejected First
My friend did everything right to steer the project—except she never had the wheel. When the car inevitably skidded off course, she was the one shown the exit. That’s what responsibility without authority leads to: casualties, not accountability.
It falls to leaders to stop issuing mandates without means. If you want results, give people clarity, power, and a steering wheel. Otherwise, you're handing them a halfway-built car—and blaming them when it crashes.