Feelings, Not Features
The Psychology That Sells
© 2025 J. Alexander Greenwood. All rights reserved. This image was created with the assistance of AI and is the intellectual property of J. Alexander Greenwood. Unauthorized reproduction, distribution, or commercial use is prohibited without express written permission.
There’s a reason you bought that overpriced pair of running shoes, even though you haven’t jogged since the Clinton administration.
It probably wasn’t the arch support or carbon-plated sole. It was the feeling. The fantasy. The whisper that you, too, could be a warrior poet in Lycra if you just slipped them on.
Welcome to the world of emotional triggers in marketing—a realm where facts take a backseat and feelings grab the wheel.
Why Logic Doesn’t Close the Sale
We like to think we’re rational creatures. That we weigh options carefully, compare specs, read the fine print. And then we make “informed” choices.
Except we don’t. Not really.
Neuroscientist Antonio Damasio discovered that people who can’t feel emotion due to brain injury struggle to make even simple decisions, like what to eat. Emotions, it turns out, aren’t distractions from rational thought. They’re the engine that powers it.
So, if your marketing strategy is leading with bullet points and dry data, you’re asking people to buy with a part of their brain that’s just along for the ride.
Let me put it this way: facts tell, emotions sell.
The Brands That Know You Better Than You Know Yourself
Take Nike. They don’t sell footwear. They sell identity, rebellion, perseverance.
When the Swoosh launched a campaign featuring Colin Kaepernick, it wasn’t about shoes, it was about choosing sides. And in doing so, they deepened loyalty with a segment of their audience who saw themselves in that choice. It was emotional calculus.
Apple? They sell control. Security. A little elitism wrapped in brushed aluminum.
Their privacy-forward messaging isn't just a tech spec; it’s a shot of dopamine for people worried about Big Brother.
Disney? Nostalgia, wonder, legacy. Coca-Cola? Connection. Warm fuzzies. The idea that cracking open a soda somehow heals generational rifts at the family barbecue.
These brands are tapping into your emotional circuitry. And it works.
Emotional Triggers That Actually Work (And How to Use Them)
Below is a field-tested list of emotional triggers and ways you can use them in PR, copywriting, or brand messaging. Think of it as a cheat sheet for the human psyche:
Emotional Triggers and Messaging Tactics
🛡️ Trust
Messaging: Use testimonials, guarantees, or certifications. Frame your brand as reliable, consistent, and transparent.
Example:
"Over 1 million satisfied users—and a 30-day money-back guarantee."
Think: Amazon’s “Verified Purchase” reviews or McAfee’s site security badges on checkout pages.
👥 Belonging
Messaging: Use inclusive language like “Join us” or “Be part of something bigger.”
Example:
"Welcome to the community of creators who are changing the game."
Think: Substack’s “Join the conversation” or Peloton’s tribe-like branding.
⚠️ Fear
Messaging: “Don’t get left behind.” “Protect what matters.” Use sparingly and ethically.
Example:
"What if your backups fail tomorrow? Be ready."
Think: LifeLock’s ID theft campaigns or Apple’s privacy-centric iPhone ads.
🌅 Hope
Messaging: Paint a better future. Inspire optimism and progress.
Example:
"What if your commute gave you your life back? Try remote work today."
Think: Salesforce’s “The Future of Work” ads or any visionary B2B SaaS storytelling.
⚖️ Guilt
Messaging: Tap into conscience. Often used in cause-based or nonprofit appeals.
Example:
"While you read this, another child is going without clean water."
Think: UNICEF, ASPCA, or St. Jude’s emotionally charged donation asks.
🏆 Pride
Messaging: Elevate the customer: “You’ve earned this.” “Smart people choose…”
Example:
"The bourbon of choice for those who know better."
Think: Lexus’s “Experience Amazing” or LinkedIn’s “You’re more than your job title.”
🔒 Exclusivity
Messaging: “Invite-only.” “Limited spots.” “You’ve been selected…”
Example:
"You're one of the few invited to beta test the new platform."
Think: Clubhouse’s original launch strategy or AmEx Black Card status appeal.
📼 Nostalgia
Messaging: Reference simpler times or tap cultural memory.
Example:
"Just like Saturday mornings with your favorite cereal—now in podcast form."
Think: Coca-Cola’s Christmas trucks, Stranger Things marketing, or retro diner-themed ads.
🔍 Curiosity
Messaging: Tease, don’t tell: “The one thing you’re missing…”
Example:
"We found a simple change that doubled conversions—want to see what it was?"
Think: BuzzFeed-style hooks, LinkedIn thought leadership posts, or YouTube thumbnail copy.
🎁 Surprise
Messaging: Delight with the unexpected. Break the pattern.
Example:
"We added something to your order. No charge. Just because."
Think: Chewy sending flowers when your pet dies or Spotify Wrapped’s unexpected reveal.
⏳ Urgency
Messaging: Create FOMO—ethically. “Only 3 spots left.” “Ends at midnight.”
Example:
"Enroll by Friday and get an exclusive 1:1 strategy session."
Think: Early bird registration deadlines or Ticketmaster “only 2 seats left!” nudges.
What This Means for PR Pros
If you're in public relations, this isn’t just a marketing parlor trick. Emotional triggers are baked into our best work—even if we don’t always name them that way.
When you pitch a story to a journalist, you're not just selling a headline—you're inviting them to care. Curiosity might get them to open the email, but it's urgency, hope, or human connection that gets the story greenlit. That happens when you answer the question “Why should anyone give a damn?”
It’s the same in a press release. Don’t just say your university won an award—connect it to why that recognition matters. Does it build trust in your brand? Show progress toward a bigger goal? Reflect pride in your community? That’s where emotion lives.
In crisis comms, trust and transparency are everything, but again, the “why” makes it stick. Don’t just say, “We’re investigating.” Say, “Because the people we serve deserve better.” That reframes cold facts as a shared value.
And when you’re building long-term reputation? That’s the domain of pride, belonging, and aspiration. Show people how they’re part of something meaningful. Tell them why it matters and why it matters now.
Bottom line: Emotional triggers don’t replace the facts. They give people a reason to care about them.
Remember Who You Are Speaking To
Whether you're writing a press release, scripting a podcast intro, or crafting your next killer LinkedIn post, remember this: you're not speaking to an audience of robots. You're reaching into people's emotional core.
Lead with the feeling. Anchor with the fact. Then give them a story where they’re the hero—and your brand is the sidekick that helps them win.
That’s not manipulation. That’s human.
Want more insights like this? Subscribe and share “All the Fits That’s News” with a friend who’s still leading their pitch with a bulleted list of product specs.